BIBLIOGRAPHY COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL ...
BIBLIOGRAPHY
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012. Different Root Crops as Ingredient for
Embutido. Benguet State University, La Trinidad, Benguet.
Adviser: Jones K. Feleciano, EdD.
ABSTRACT
The study was conducted to determine the acceptability of embutido processed with
different root crops; to determine the production cost and profitability; to determine the
nutrient content and the shelf life of the products.
A total of 25 panelists were invited to evaluate the processed embutido with
different root crops. The panels of tasters were composed of five persons from students,
teachers, house wives, employees and food servers.
The products were evaluated in terms of appearance, tenderness, juiciness
acceptability and aroma. As for tenderness, embutido with carrots, ube and sugar beets
were rated very tender, while embutido with carrots and sweet potato was rated by the
panelists as moderately tender. In terms of appearance, the panelist rated embutido
processed with carrots, sweet potato, and sugar beets as very good and embutido with ube
as good. For juiciness, all of the products were rated as moderately juicy. For acceptability
embutido with carrots, sweet potato, sugar beets were rated as like very much while
embutido with ube was rated as like moderately. For aroma like very much were the verbal
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
description for embutido with carrots, embutido with sweet potato and embutido with sugar
beets. And for embutido with ube it was rated with like moderately.
Nonetheless, results of statistical analysis revealed that there were no significant
differences among the treatments.
The shelf life of the products was evaluated under room temperature. The products
with carrot, ube and sweet potato deteriorated three days from the time of processing as
exhibited by the presence molds and its foul odor, except for the embutido with sugar beets
which deteriorated on the fourth day. The shelf life evaluation started on May 9, 2011 and
ended on May 13, 2011 which was the deterioration of all the treatments.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
INTRODUCTION
Food preferences after influenced by many interacting factors, such as income,
culture, concerns about health, social values and religions. Yet for most persons and in
ordinary circumstances, food must be palatable or have appetite appeal if they are to be
eaten. Learning to prepare foods with great appetite appeal includes learning to
discriminate and evaluate the quality of food through the intensity of the sensations
received when food is sampled.
Meat like any food can be prepared in various ways to enhance its appetite appeal.
One of the meat-based dishes is embutido, a Filipino style meat loaf.
Embutido is one of the most favorite Filipino dishes. It can be served as cold cuts;
lightly pan sliced pieces or fried the whole then slice. Different root crops like ube, sugar
beets and sweet potato can be a substitute for carrot. These root crops would add flavors,
colors, and nutrients that we could not get from carrots. Since all of them have a unique
taste and unique nutrient contents that are needed by our body.
Root crops such as ube, carrots, sugar beets sweet potato are rich in nutrients that
make our body healthy. These are also used as herbal medicines. Sugar beets have been
shown to lessen tumor cells. Recent studies have likewise shown the superior ability of
sweet potatoes to raise our blood levels of vitamin A. Carrots on the other hand are an
excellent source of anti oxidant and many more health benefits that root crops can give.
The main reason why we change carrot and substitute it with other root crops is to explore
and make new recipe, to satisfy the taste of consumers and we can get other nutrients that
are not present in carrot alone (Anonymous 2001).
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
This study is to provide knowledge and information to processors who are
interested to engage in Embutido making with the use of different root crops like ube, sugar
beet and sweet potato as extenders in place of carrot.
This was conducted to determine the acceptability of Embutido processed with
different root crops, to determine the production cost and profitability, and to determine
the nutrient content and shelf life of the products.
This study was conducted at the Meat Processing Laboratory, Department of
Animal Science College of Agriculture, Benguet State University, La Trinidad, Benguet
from May to June 2011.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
In 1983, Ibarra stated three reasons why man eats meat. First it provides satiety
unequaled to other food items. An individual who eats meat with a meat dish feels satisfied
for a long period. Secondly is meat can be prepared in variety of ways that is why it can
never be monotonous to taste of consumer. There are many recipes where meat is utilized
singly or in combination with other food items. Meat is probably the only single food
material which can be prepared in many ways. Third, meat provides nutrient almost in the
proportion and amount needed by a human body, especially in terms of protein. He also
mentioned however that meat is highly perishable. Without proper handling when exposed
to surroundings, spoilage will readily occur.
According to Labensky and Hause (2003) Standardized recipes are not found in
books or provided by manufacturers. They are recipe customized to your operation. A
recipe must be tested repeatedly and adjusted to fit your facility and your needs before it
can be considered standardized. They also added that modern food preservation, storage
and transportation technique have made both fresh exotic foods regularly available to chefs
and consumers.
Staub (1982) Stated that embutido is a ground pork dish with seasoning garnish
rolled and wrapped in leaf or panyu-panyu and being steamed. It is served in slice like meat
loaf. Well flavored juicy meat with minimum loss of shrinkage. Steaming under pressure
is fast and easy, saves on energy and provides accurate meat proportioning and cost control.
Dio-al (2005) said that when steaming meat, minimum shrinkage occurs and it is
one of the healthiest methods of cooking because no additional fat is used. Although water
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
is used in the process as in boiling, the meat retains more nutrients because it does not sit
directly in water, preventing the nutrient from being leached out from the meat.
Carrot
The nutrient content of 1 serving or 122g of fresh Carrot (Daucus carota) is as follows
(USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, 2011):
Component
Nutrient Value
Water
107.71 g
Calories
50
Protein
1.13 g
Carbohydrates
11.69 g
Fiber
3.4 g
Sugars
5.54 g
Total Fat
0.29 g
Saturated Fat
0.045 g
Monounsaturated Fat
0.017 g
Polyunsaturated Fat
0.143 g
Calcium
40 mg
Iron
0.37 mg
Magnesium
15 mg
Phosphorus
43 mg
Potassium
390 mg
Sodium
84 mg
Zinc
0.29 mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Vitamin C
7.2 mg
Thiamin
0.081 mg
Riboflavin
0.071 mg
Niacin
1.199 mg
Pantothenic Acid
0.333 mg
Vitamin B6
0.168 mg
Folate
23 mcg
Vitamin A
20509 IU
Vitamin E
0.81 mg
Vitamin K
16.1 mcg
Beta Carotene
10108 mcg
Beta Cryptoxanthin
153 mcg
Lycopene
1 mcg
Lutein and Zeaxanthin
312 mcg
Ube
Ensminger et. al. (1983) Yams are a good source of vitamin B6. This vitamin is
needed by the body to break down a substance called homocysteine, which can directly
damage blood vessel walls. Individuals who suffer a heart attack despite having normal or
even low cholesterol levels are often found to have high levels of homocysteine. Since high
homocysteine levels are significantly associated with increased risk of heart attack and
stroke, having a good supply Vitamin B6 on hand makes a great deal of sense. High intakes
of vitamin B6 have also been shown to reduce the risk of heart disease.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Anonymous (2001) Stated that yams' complex carbohydrates and fiber deliver the
goods gradually, slowing the rate at which their sugars are released and absorbed into the
bloodstream. In addition, because they're rich in fiber, yams fill you up without filling out
your hips and waistline. And one more benefit, yams are a good source of manganese, a
trace mineral that helps with carbohydrate metabolism and is a cofactor in a number of
enzymes important in energy production and antioxidant defenses.
The nutrient content of 1 serving or 125g of fresh Yam (Dioscorea alata) is as follows
(USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, 2011):
2001)
Component Nutrient Value
Calories 177
Protein 2.3g
Carbohydrate 41.8g
Total Fat 0.25g
6.1g Fiber 6.1g
Potassium 1224mg
Vitamin C 25.6mg
Vitamin B6 0.44mg
Thiamine 0.168mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Sweet Potato
Anonymous (2005) Cited that sweet potatoes have been found to contain a high
amount of anti-oxidant, making it suitable in combating inflammatory problems like
asthma, arthritis, gout. When we are stressed, our metabolic rate rises, causing the body
potassium levels to be reduced. By snacking on the potassium-packed sweet potato, it helps
to rebalance the vital mineral, and helps normalize the heartbeat. This in turn sends oxygen
to the brain and regulates the body's water balance. High potassium root helps to prevent
heart attack and stroke. It helps maintain fluid and electrolyte balance in the body cells, as
well as normal heart function and blood pressure.
The nutrient content of 1 serving or 77g of Sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas), baked, with
skin is as follows (The George Mateljan Foundation, 2001):
Component Nutrient
Value
Calories 95.39
Vitamin A
13107.70IU
Vitamin C
17.06 mg
Manganese
0.52 mg
Copper
0.26 mg
Dietary fiber
3.14 g
Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine)
0.25 mg
Potassium
306.05 mg
Iron
1.46 mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Sugar Beets
Relf D. and McDaniel. (2009) stated that beets may be grown for both their greens
and their roots. They are heavy yielders and high in iron and vitamins. Beets come in
several color and shapes. In addition to the standard dark red, orange and white varieties
are available. The lighter varieties do not bleed their color as readily, but are less attractive
in canning jars and on the plate than the red ones. Round beets are most common, but flat
and oblong types are grown as well. Flat and round beets tend to be early maturing varieties,
while the long cylindrical beets are usually late maturing. They also added that the beet
seed is actually a fruit with one to four seeds enclosed. Thinning is usually necessary for
this reason. Crushing them lightly with a rolling pin will allow individual seed to separate
and reduce the amount of thinning required. Soaking the fruits may enhance germination.
Plant at three-week intervals for a continuous harvest.
The nutrient content of 1 serving or 100g of Sugar Beets (Beta vulgaris), raw is as
follows (USDA National Nutrient data base, 2009):
Component
Nutrient Value
Carbohydrates
9.56 g
Protein
1.61 g
Total Fat
0.17 g
Dietary Fiber
2.80 g
Folates
109 mcg
Niacin
0.334 mg
Pantothenic acid
0.155 mg
Pyridoxine
0.067 mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Riboflavin
0.057 mg
Thiamin
0.031 mg
Vitamin A
33 IU
Vitamin C
4.9 mg
Vitamin E
0.04 mg
Vitamin K
0.2 mcg
Sodium
78 mg
Potassium
325 mg
Calcium
16 mg
Copper
0.075 mg
Iron
0.80 mg
Magnesium
23 mg
Manganese
0.329 mg
Zinc
0.35 mg
Carotene-ß
20 mcg
Betaine
128.7 mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study used the following common ingredients of embutido namely: ground pork,
refined salt, ground black pepper, onion, raisins, hotdog, cornstarch, garlic, sugar, eggs,
bread crumbs, soy sauce, cheese and cooking oil.
In addition to these common ingredients of embutido, this research study used as carrots,
ube, sweet potato and sugar beets. These root crops were assigned to the different
treatments and served as treatments.
The utensils include the following: refrigerator, weighing scale, cooking stove,
steamer, mixing bowl, measuring spoons and cups, chopping board, knives, pan and
spatula.
The same ingredients were used in all treatments except for the root crop added to
them. The treatments are as follows:
T0-usual embutido ingredient with 250grams fresh grated carrots (Figures 1 to 3)
T1- usual embutido ingredient with 250 grams fresh grated ube (Figures 4to 6)
T2- usual embutido ingredient with 250grams fresh grated sweet potato (Figures 7
to 9)
T3- usual embutido ingredient with 250 g grams fresh grated sugar beets (Figures 10
to 12)
Procedure in Making Embutido
Experimental treatments. There were four treatments in the study and each
treatment was replicated three times. One kilogram of ground pork was used for each
replication. The ingredients (Table 1) were measured, added and mixed with the meat by
hand until the mixture became tacky.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 1. 250g Grated carrots
Figure 2. Mixture of all ingredients
Figure 3. Processed product
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 4. 250g Grated ube
Figure 5. Mixture of all ingredients
Figure 6. Processed product
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 7. 250g Grated sweet potato
Figure 8. Mixture of all ingredients
Figure 9. Processed product
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 10. 250g Sugar beets
Figure 11. Mixture of all ingredients
b
Figure 12. Processed product
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
The mixture (Figures 2, 5, 8 and 11) was spread in an aluminum foil (250gms),
allowing one inch on each side. The said mixture was rolled on both ends and steamed for
one hour. After it was removed from the steamer and cooled (Figures 3, 6, 9 and 12). It
was later chilled in the refrigerator, unwrapped and fried until golden brown.
Organoleptic test. Each cooked samples (Figures 13 to 16) was sliced and subjected
to acceptability taste by three sets panel of tasters which represented each replicate in the
treatments. Each set of panel composed of five teachers, five students, five expert food
servers, five house wives and five employees. Each member of the panel was given score
cards for their respective ratings for each treatment.
Table 1. Ingredients used for every kilogram of meat.
CURING MIX
SEASONINGS
TREATMENTS
Salt and pepper 1cup finely chopped hotdog 250g grated carrots
½ cup sweet relish 250g grated ube
3 whole eggs 250g grated sweet potato
½ cup grated cheese 250g grated sugar beets
2 tbsp. corn starch
½ cup raisins
1bulb garlic
1 onion bulb chopped finely
2 tbsp. sugar
3tbsp. bread crumbs
2 tbsp. soy sauce
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 13. Embutido with carrots after deep Figure 14. Embutido with ube after deep
frying frying
Figure 15. Embutido with sweet potato Figure 16. Embutido with sugar beets
after deep frying after deep frying
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
The data gathered were:
1. Appearance of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score
Remarks
1 Very good
2 Good
3 Fair
2. Tenderness of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score Remarks
1
Very Tender
2
Moderately Tender
3
Tough
3. Juiciness of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score Remarks
1
Very Juicy
2
Moderately Juicy
3
Not Juicy
4. Acceptability of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score Remarks
1
Like Very Much
2
Like Moderately
3
Dislike
5. Aroma of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score Remarks
1 Very pleasing
2 Moderately pleasing
3 Not pleasing
6. Shelf Life. This was determined at room temperature from the time the embutido was
processed until growth of molds was observed.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
7. Total Cost Production (TCP). This was computed by getting the total of the direct cost
and indirect cost.
8. Nutrition facts. This was obtained by the DOST-CAR Km6, La Trinidad, Benguet.
9. Return on Investment. This was obtained by dividing the net income by total cost of
production and multiplied by 100.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Appearance
Table 2 shows the result of the evaluation of the tasters on the appearance of
embutido processed with different root crops. Result show that embutido processed with
carrots, sweet potato and sugar beets were all rated very good while embutido with ube
was rated good.
Statistical analysis shows no significant differences among treatments. There was
difference in numerical and verbal description, but was not enough to cause a significant
deviation.
Tenderness
Table 3 shows the tenderness of embutido as evaluated by the panelists. The
embutido with carrots, ube and sugar beets were rated very tender, while the embutido with
sweet potato was rated moderately tender.
Statistical analysis revealed no significant differences among treatments. There was
difference in numerical and verbal description, but was not enough to cause a significant
differences.
Table 2. Appearance of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.32 Very Good
Embutido with ube 1.59 Good
Embutido with sweet potato 1.39 Very Good
Embutido with sugar beets 1.35 Very Good
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 3. Tenderness of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.46 Moderately Tender
Embutido with ube 1.43 Very Tender
Embutido with sweet potato 1.59 Moderately Tender
Embutido with sugar beets 1.39 Very Tender
Juiciness
Table 4 shows that embutido in different treatments were all rated as moderately
juicy by the panelists. Numerically, they had differences, embutido processed with carrots
had 1.69, embutido with ube had 1.71, embutido with sweet potato had 1.73 and embutido
with sugarbeets had 1.65. based on the verbal description of the tasters, the products under
the different treatments were all moderately juicy, thus, resulting to no significant
differences among the treatments.
Acceptability
Table 5 shows the acceptability evaluation of embutido with different root crops.
Embutido with carrots, embutido with sweet potato and embutido with sugar beets were
rated likely very much while embutido with ube was rated like moderately.
Analysis revealed that there are no significant differences among treatments. There was
difference in numerical and verbal description, but was not enough to cause a significant
deviation.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 4. Juiciness of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.69 Moderately Juicy
Embutido with ube 1.71 Moderately Juicy
Embutido with sweet potato 1.73 Moderately Juicy
Embutido with sugar beets 1.65 Moderately Juicy
Table 5. Acceptability of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.39 Like Very Much
Embutido with ube 1.56 Like Moderately
Embutido with Sweet Potato 1.44 Like Very Much
Embutido with Sugar Beets 1.47 Like Very Much
Aroma
Table 6 revealed the result of the aroma as affected by different treatments. It shows
that embutido with carrots, embutido with sweet potato and embutido with sugar beets were
rated by the panelists very pleasing, but based on the numerical value embutido processed
with carrots had the highest value for aroma, and moderately pleasing was the verbal
description for embutido with ube.
Analysis shows no significant differences among treatments. This implies that the different
treatments did not affect the aroma of the products.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 6. Aroma of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.36 Very Pleasing
Embutido with ube 1.57 Moderately Pleasing
Embutido with Sweet Potato 1.4 Very Pleasing
Embutido with Sugar Beets 1.47 Very Pleasing
Shelf Life Evaluation
The processed products were observed on the number of days molds appeared.
Embutido with carrots (Figure 17), ube (Figure 18) and sweet potato (Figure 19) exhibited
molds on the 3rd day, while embutido with sugar beets exhibited molds on the 4th day
(Figure 20).
Total Cost of Processed products
The cost of production (Table 7) shows the expenses incurred in processing embutido.
Differences on the expenses incurred in producing embutido are attributed to the
differences in prices of the extenders used. The embutido with sugarbeets had the highest
expense of 323.8225 pesos, while embutido with sweet potato had the lowest expense of
316.3425 pesos.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 7. Total cost of processed embutido per kilogram (Php)
EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO
PROCESSED PROCESSED PROCESSED PROCESSED
INGREDIENTS WITH 250g WITH 250g WITH 250g WITH 250g
CARROTS UBE SWEET SUGAR
POTATO BEETS
Refined salt 0.14 0 .14 0.14 0 .14
Onion 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44
Raisins 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50
Hotdog 27.50 27.50 27.50 27.50
Cornstarch 1.50 1.50 1.50 1.50
Eggs 8.67 8.67 8.67 8.67
Soy 0.68 0.68 0.68 0.68
Cheese 20.25 20.25 20.25 20.25
Bread Crumbs 6.50 6.50 6.50 6.50
Cooking oil 10.83 10.83 10.83 10.83
Garlic 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00
Pickle relish 13.25 13.25 13.25 13.25
Magic sarap 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00
Pork meat 180 180 180 180
Sugar 1.19 1.19 1.19 1.19
Carrot 12.50 - - -
Ube - 13 - -
Sweet potato - - 10 -
Sugar Beets - - - 17
Direct cost 299.95 300.45 297.45 307.45
Indirect cost 18.9975 19.0225 18.8725 19.3725
Total cost of
Production (php) 318.9475 319.4725 316.3425 323.8225
Gross Income 325 325 325 325
Net Income 6.0525 5.5275 8.6575 1.1775
ROI (%) 1.90 1.73 2.74 0.36
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 17. Appearance of embutido with Figure 18. Appearance of embutido with
carrots at 3rd day ube at 3rd day
Figure 19. Appearance of embutido with Figure 20. Appearance of embutido with
sweet potato at 3rd day sugar beets at 4th day
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Nutrition Fact Analysis
Table 8 shows the result of the nutritional content analysis of embutido processed with
different root crops as analyzed by the Department of Science and Technology, Km.6, La
Trinidad, Benguet.
Ash content. Embutido with sweet potato had 2.56% in every 250 grams, embutido with
sugar beets had 2.07%, embutido with carrots had 1.95% and embutido with ube has
1.40%.
Carbohydrates content. Embutido with sweet potato had 20.24% followed by embutido
with sugar beets with 15.85%, embutido with carrots with 12.60% and embutido with ube
with 12.44%.
Crude fat content. Embutido with ube had 9.51%, followed by embutido with sweet potato
had 8.19%, embutido with carrots had 7.89% and embutido with sugar beets had 6.46%.
Crude protein content. Embutido with carrots had 13.6%, then embutido with ube had
12.9%, embutido with sugar beets had 11.32% and embutido with sweet potato had 9.29%.
Moisture content. Embutido with ube had 64.56%, followed by embutido with carrots had
64.51%, embutido with sugar beets had 64.30% and embutido with sweet potato had
59.72%.
Energy content. Embutido with sweet potato had 192kcal, followed by embutido with ube
which is 184kcal, then embutido with carrots which is 174kcal, and lastly the embutido
with sugar beets which contains 167kcal.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 8. Nutrition Facts Analysis as analyzed by the DOST
EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO
NUTRIENT PROCESSED PROCESSED PROCESSED PROCESSED
CONTENT WITH 250g WITH 250g WITH 250g WITH 250g
CARROTS UBE SWEET SUGAR
POTATO BEETS
Ash, % 1.95 1.40 2.56 2.07
Carbohydrate, % 12.60 12.44 20.24 15.85
Crude Fat, % 7.89 9.51 8.19 6.46
Crude protein, % 13.06 12.09 9.29 11.32
Moisture, % 64.51 64.56 59.72 64.30
Energy, kcal 174 184 192 167
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
Summary
This was conducted at the Meat Processing Laboratory, Department of Animal
Science, College of Agriculture, Benguet State University, La Trinidad, Benguet. The
study was conducted to determine the acceptability of embutido processed with different
root crops, to determine the production cost and profitability, to determine the nutrient
content and to determine the shelf life of the products. A total of 25 panelists were invited
to evaluate the processed embutido with different root crops. The panels of tasters are
composed of five persons from students, teachers, house wives, employees and food
servers.
The products were evaluated in terms of appearance, tenderness, juiciness
acceptability and aroma. As for tenderness, embutido with carrots, ube and sugar beets
were rated very tender while embutido with carrots and sweet potato was rated by the
panelists as moderately tender. In terms of appearance the panelist rated embutido
processed with carrots, sweet potato, and sugar beets as very good and embutido with ube
as good. For juiciness, all of the products were rated as moderately juicy. For acceptability
embutido with carrots, sweet potato, sugar beets were rated as like very much while
embutido with ube was rated as like moderately. For aroma, embutido with carrots,
embutido with sweet potato and embutido with sugar beets were rated like very much,
while embutido with ube it was rated like moderately.
Nonetheless, results of statistical analysis revealed that there were no significant
differences among the treatments.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
The shelf life of the products was evaluated under room temperature. The products
with carrot, ube and sweet potato deteriorated three days from the time of processing as
exhibited by the presence molds and its foul odor, except for the embutido with sugar beets
which deteriorated on the fourth day. The shelf life evaluation started on May 9, 2011 and
ended on May 13, 2011 which was the deterioration of all the treatments.
Conclusion
Based on the result of the study it is concluded that ube, sweet potato and sugar
beets can be used as alternative extenders for embutido. It is also concluded that the use
of sweet potato as extender can lower the cost production. In addition, adding sugar beets
could lengthen the shelf life of the product and its reddish color enhances the appearance
of the product which makes it more attractive.
Recommendation
To maximize profit, it is recommended that sweet potato be used as extender for
embutido because of its lower price as compared to carrots, ube and sugar beets. Based on
the result of organoleptic test by the tasters, it is generally acceptable. Thus, guaranteeing
its marketability and viability in the market. Moreover, it contains the highest energy
content (192kcal) as compared to other root crops used.
Even so, the other root crops could still be used as extenders for embutido to provide
consumers choices. Not to mention, consumers have different preferences.
Since this study is limited only on the data provided and gathered, it is
recommended that further studies be conducted to validate the results.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
LITERATURE CITED
ANONYMOUS. 2001. The World’s Healthiest Food. Retrieved April 21, 2011from
http://www.whfoods.com.
ANONYMOUS. 2005. Sweet Potato Nutrition Information and Facts. Retrieved May 6,
2011from http://www.juicing-for-health.com/carrot-nutrition.html.
DIO-AL, T. D. 2005. Evaluation of different Meat as Embutido. BS Thesis. Benguet State
University, La Trinidad Benguet. P4.
ESMINGER A.H. ME Ensminger, JE Kondale, JRK Robson. 1983 Foods and Nutrition
Encyclopedia. Pegus Press, Clovis, California 1983.
IBARRA, P. I. 1983. Meat Processing for Small and Medium Care Operations. University
of the Philippines. Los Banos, Laguna. Pp. 182-189.
LABENSKYand HAUSE 2003. On Cooking, Techniques from Expert Chefs. 3rd Edition.
New Jersy 07458.
RELF D. AND McDANIEL A. 2009. Root Crops Home Virginia Cooperative Extension.
Virginia State University. Retrieved May4, 2011. Http://pubs.ext.vt.edu/426/426-
422/426-422.html.
STAUB, A. 1982. The Science of Philippine Foods 2nd Edition. Abanido Enterprise.
Araneta Center Quezon City, Philippines. P338
The MATELJAN FOUNDATION.2O11. Sweet Potato Nutrition information and Facts.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweet Potato.
UNITED STATES FOOD and DRUGS ADMINISTRATION 2009. Beets Nutrition
Facts. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/beet.
UNITED STATES FOOD and DRUGS ADMINISTRATION 2009. Nutrition: Nutrient
content of Ube. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/yam.
UNITED STATES FOOD and DRUGS ADMINISTRATION 2009. Juicing for health
Carrot Nutrition Fact. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/carrot.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012. Different Root Crops as Ingredient for
Embutido. Benguet State University, La Trinidad, Benguet.
Adviser: Jones K. Feleciano, EdD.
ABSTRACT
The study was conducted to determine the acceptability of embutido processed with
different root crops; to determine the production cost and profitability; to determine the
nutrient content and the shelf life of the products.
A total of 25 panelists were invited to evaluate the processed embutido with
different root crops. The panels of tasters were composed of five persons from students,
teachers, house wives, employees and food servers.
The products were evaluated in terms of appearance, tenderness, juiciness
acceptability and aroma. As for tenderness, embutido with carrots, ube and sugar beets
were rated very tender, while embutido with carrots and sweet potato was rated by the
panelists as moderately tender. In terms of appearance, the panelist rated embutido
processed with carrots, sweet potato, and sugar beets as very good and embutido with ube
as good. For juiciness, all of the products were rated as moderately juicy. For acceptability
embutido with carrots, sweet potato, sugar beets were rated as like very much while
embutido with ube was rated as like moderately. For aroma like very much were the verbal
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
description for embutido with carrots, embutido with sweet potato and embutido with sugar
beets. And for embutido with ube it was rated with like moderately.
Nonetheless, results of statistical analysis revealed that there were no significant
differences among the treatments.
The shelf life of the products was evaluated under room temperature. The products
with carrot, ube and sweet potato deteriorated three days from the time of processing as
exhibited by the presence molds and its foul odor, except for the embutido with sugar beets
which deteriorated on the fourth day. The shelf life evaluation started on May 9, 2011 and
ended on May 13, 2011 which was the deterioration of all the treatments.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
INTRODUCTION
Food preferences after influenced by many interacting factors, such as income,
culture, concerns about health, social values and religions. Yet for most persons and in
ordinary circumstances, food must be palatable or have appetite appeal if they are to be
eaten. Learning to prepare foods with great appetite appeal includes learning to
discriminate and evaluate the quality of food through the intensity of the sensations
received when food is sampled.
Meat like any food can be prepared in various ways to enhance its appetite appeal.
One of the meat-based dishes is embutido, a Filipino style meat loaf.
Embutido is one of the most favorite Filipino dishes. It can be served as cold cuts;
lightly pan sliced pieces or fried the whole then slice. Different root crops like ube, sugar
beets and sweet potato can be a substitute for carrot. These root crops would add flavors,
colors, and nutrients that we could not get from carrots. Since all of them have a unique
taste and unique nutrient contents that are needed by our body.
Root crops such as ube, carrots, sugar beets sweet potato are rich in nutrients that
make our body healthy. These are also used as herbal medicines. Sugar beets have been
shown to lessen tumor cells. Recent studies have likewise shown the superior ability of
sweet potatoes to raise our blood levels of vitamin A. Carrots on the other hand are an
excellent source of anti oxidant and many more health benefits that root crops can give.
The main reason why we change carrot and substitute it with other root crops is to explore
and make new recipe, to satisfy the taste of consumers and we can get other nutrients that
are not present in carrot alone (Anonymous 2001).
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
This study is to provide knowledge and information to processors who are
interested to engage in Embutido making with the use of different root crops like ube, sugar
beet and sweet potato as extenders in place of carrot.
This was conducted to determine the acceptability of Embutido processed with
different root crops, to determine the production cost and profitability, and to determine
the nutrient content and shelf life of the products.
This study was conducted at the Meat Processing Laboratory, Department of
Animal Science College of Agriculture, Benguet State University, La Trinidad, Benguet
from May to June 2011.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
In 1983, Ibarra stated three reasons why man eats meat. First it provides satiety
unequaled to other food items. An individual who eats meat with a meat dish feels satisfied
for a long period. Secondly is meat can be prepared in variety of ways that is why it can
never be monotonous to taste of consumer. There are many recipes where meat is utilized
singly or in combination with other food items. Meat is probably the only single food
material which can be prepared in many ways. Third, meat provides nutrient almost in the
proportion and amount needed by a human body, especially in terms of protein. He also
mentioned however that meat is highly perishable. Without proper handling when exposed
to surroundings, spoilage will readily occur.
According to Labensky and Hause (2003) Standardized recipes are not found in
books or provided by manufacturers. They are recipe customized to your operation. A
recipe must be tested repeatedly and adjusted to fit your facility and your needs before it
can be considered standardized. They also added that modern food preservation, storage
and transportation technique have made both fresh exotic foods regularly available to chefs
and consumers.
Staub (1982) Stated that embutido is a ground pork dish with seasoning garnish
rolled and wrapped in leaf or panyu-panyu and being steamed. It is served in slice like meat
loaf. Well flavored juicy meat with minimum loss of shrinkage. Steaming under pressure
is fast and easy, saves on energy and provides accurate meat proportioning and cost control.
Dio-al (2005) said that when steaming meat, minimum shrinkage occurs and it is
one of the healthiest methods of cooking because no additional fat is used. Although water
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
is used in the process as in boiling, the meat retains more nutrients because it does not sit
directly in water, preventing the nutrient from being leached out from the meat.
Carrot
The nutrient content of 1 serving or 122g of fresh Carrot (Daucus carota) is as follows
(USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, 2011):
Component
Nutrient Value
Water
107.71 g
Calories
50
Protein
1.13 g
Carbohydrates
11.69 g
Fiber
3.4 g
Sugars
5.54 g
Total Fat
0.29 g
Saturated Fat
0.045 g
Monounsaturated Fat
0.017 g
Polyunsaturated Fat
0.143 g
Calcium
40 mg
Iron
0.37 mg
Magnesium
15 mg
Phosphorus
43 mg
Potassium
390 mg
Sodium
84 mg
Zinc
0.29 mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Vitamin C
7.2 mg
Thiamin
0.081 mg
Riboflavin
0.071 mg
Niacin
1.199 mg
Pantothenic Acid
0.333 mg
Vitamin B6
0.168 mg
Folate
23 mcg
Vitamin A
20509 IU
Vitamin E
0.81 mg
Vitamin K
16.1 mcg
Beta Carotene
10108 mcg
Beta Cryptoxanthin
153 mcg
Lycopene
1 mcg
Lutein and Zeaxanthin
312 mcg
Ube
Ensminger et. al. (1983) Yams are a good source of vitamin B6. This vitamin is
needed by the body to break down a substance called homocysteine, which can directly
damage blood vessel walls. Individuals who suffer a heart attack despite having normal or
even low cholesterol levels are often found to have high levels of homocysteine. Since high
homocysteine levels are significantly associated with increased risk of heart attack and
stroke, having a good supply Vitamin B6 on hand makes a great deal of sense. High intakes
of vitamin B6 have also been shown to reduce the risk of heart disease.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Anonymous (2001) Stated that yams' complex carbohydrates and fiber deliver the
goods gradually, slowing the rate at which their sugars are released and absorbed into the
bloodstream. In addition, because they're rich in fiber, yams fill you up without filling out
your hips and waistline. And one more benefit, yams are a good source of manganese, a
trace mineral that helps with carbohydrate metabolism and is a cofactor in a number of
enzymes important in energy production and antioxidant defenses.
The nutrient content of 1 serving or 125g of fresh Yam (Dioscorea alata) is as follows
(USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, 2011):
2001)
Component Nutrient Value
Calories 177
Protein 2.3g
Carbohydrate 41.8g
Total Fat 0.25g
6.1g Fiber 6.1g
Potassium 1224mg
Vitamin C 25.6mg
Vitamin B6 0.44mg
Thiamine 0.168mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Sweet Potato
Anonymous (2005) Cited that sweet potatoes have been found to contain a high
amount of anti-oxidant, making it suitable in combating inflammatory problems like
asthma, arthritis, gout. When we are stressed, our metabolic rate rises, causing the body
potassium levels to be reduced. By snacking on the potassium-packed sweet potato, it helps
to rebalance the vital mineral, and helps normalize the heartbeat. This in turn sends oxygen
to the brain and regulates the body's water balance. High potassium root helps to prevent
heart attack and stroke. It helps maintain fluid and electrolyte balance in the body cells, as
well as normal heart function and blood pressure.
The nutrient content of 1 serving or 77g of Sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas), baked, with
skin is as follows (The George Mateljan Foundation, 2001):
Component Nutrient
Value
Calories 95.39
Vitamin A
13107.70IU
Vitamin C
17.06 mg
Manganese
0.52 mg
Copper
0.26 mg
Dietary fiber
3.14 g
Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine)
0.25 mg
Potassium
306.05 mg
Iron
1.46 mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Sugar Beets
Relf D. and McDaniel. (2009) stated that beets may be grown for both their greens
and their roots. They are heavy yielders and high in iron and vitamins. Beets come in
several color and shapes. In addition to the standard dark red, orange and white varieties
are available. The lighter varieties do not bleed their color as readily, but are less attractive
in canning jars and on the plate than the red ones. Round beets are most common, but flat
and oblong types are grown as well. Flat and round beets tend to be early maturing varieties,
while the long cylindrical beets are usually late maturing. They also added that the beet
seed is actually a fruit with one to four seeds enclosed. Thinning is usually necessary for
this reason. Crushing them lightly with a rolling pin will allow individual seed to separate
and reduce the amount of thinning required. Soaking the fruits may enhance germination.
Plant at three-week intervals for a continuous harvest.
The nutrient content of 1 serving or 100g of Sugar Beets (Beta vulgaris), raw is as
follows (USDA National Nutrient data base, 2009):
Component
Nutrient Value
Carbohydrates
9.56 g
Protein
1.61 g
Total Fat
0.17 g
Dietary Fiber
2.80 g
Folates
109 mcg
Niacin
0.334 mg
Pantothenic acid
0.155 mg
Pyridoxine
0.067 mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Riboflavin
0.057 mg
Thiamin
0.031 mg
Vitamin A
33 IU
Vitamin C
4.9 mg
Vitamin E
0.04 mg
Vitamin K
0.2 mcg
Sodium
78 mg
Potassium
325 mg
Calcium
16 mg
Copper
0.075 mg
Iron
0.80 mg
Magnesium
23 mg
Manganese
0.329 mg
Zinc
0.35 mg
Carotene-ß
20 mcg
Betaine
128.7 mg
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study used the following common ingredients of embutido namely: ground pork,
refined salt, ground black pepper, onion, raisins, hotdog, cornstarch, garlic, sugar, eggs,
bread crumbs, soy sauce, cheese and cooking oil.
In addition to these common ingredients of embutido, this research study used as carrots,
ube, sweet potato and sugar beets. These root crops were assigned to the different
treatments and served as treatments.
The utensils include the following: refrigerator, weighing scale, cooking stove,
steamer, mixing bowl, measuring spoons and cups, chopping board, knives, pan and
spatula.
The same ingredients were used in all treatments except for the root crop added to
them. The treatments are as follows:
T0-usual embutido ingredient with 250grams fresh grated carrots (Figures 1 to 3)
T1- usual embutido ingredient with 250 grams fresh grated ube (Figures 4to 6)
T2- usual embutido ingredient with 250grams fresh grated sweet potato (Figures 7
to 9)
T3- usual embutido ingredient with 250 g grams fresh grated sugar beets (Figures 10
to 12)
Procedure in Making Embutido
Experimental treatments. There were four treatments in the study and each
treatment was replicated three times. One kilogram of ground pork was used for each
replication. The ingredients (Table 1) were measured, added and mixed with the meat by
hand until the mixture became tacky.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 1. 250g Grated carrots
Figure 2. Mixture of all ingredients
Figure 3. Processed product
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 4. 250g Grated ube
Figure 5. Mixture of all ingredients
Figure 6. Processed product
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 7. 250g Grated sweet potato
Figure 8. Mixture of all ingredients
Figure 9. Processed product
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 10. 250g Sugar beets
Figure 11. Mixture of all ingredients
b
Figure 12. Processed product
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
The mixture (Figures 2, 5, 8 and 11) was spread in an aluminum foil (250gms),
allowing one inch on each side. The said mixture was rolled on both ends and steamed for
one hour. After it was removed from the steamer and cooled (Figures 3, 6, 9 and 12). It
was later chilled in the refrigerator, unwrapped and fried until golden brown.
Organoleptic test. Each cooked samples (Figures 13 to 16) was sliced and subjected
to acceptability taste by three sets panel of tasters which represented each replicate in the
treatments. Each set of panel composed of five teachers, five students, five expert food
servers, five house wives and five employees. Each member of the panel was given score
cards for their respective ratings for each treatment.
Table 1. Ingredients used for every kilogram of meat.
CURING MIX
SEASONINGS
TREATMENTS
Salt and pepper 1cup finely chopped hotdog 250g grated carrots
½ cup sweet relish 250g grated ube
3 whole eggs 250g grated sweet potato
½ cup grated cheese 250g grated sugar beets
2 tbsp. corn starch
½ cup raisins
1bulb garlic
1 onion bulb chopped finely
2 tbsp. sugar
3tbsp. bread crumbs
2 tbsp. soy sauce
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 13. Embutido with carrots after deep Figure 14. Embutido with ube after deep
frying frying
Figure 15. Embutido with sweet potato Figure 16. Embutido with sugar beets
after deep frying after deep frying
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
The data gathered were:
1. Appearance of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score
Remarks
1 Very good
2 Good
3 Fair
2. Tenderness of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score Remarks
1
Very Tender
2
Moderately Tender
3
Tough
3. Juiciness of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score Remarks
1
Very Juicy
2
Moderately Juicy
3
Not Juicy
4. Acceptability of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score Remarks
1
Like Very Much
2
Like Moderately
3
Dislike
5. Aroma of the product. This was evaluated using the scale below:
Score Remarks
1 Very pleasing
2 Moderately pleasing
3 Not pleasing
6. Shelf Life. This was determined at room temperature from the time the embutido was
processed until growth of molds was observed.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
7. Total Cost Production (TCP). This was computed by getting the total of the direct cost
and indirect cost.
8. Nutrition facts. This was obtained by the DOST-CAR Km6, La Trinidad, Benguet.
9. Return on Investment. This was obtained by dividing the net income by total cost of
production and multiplied by 100.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Appearance
Table 2 shows the result of the evaluation of the tasters on the appearance of
embutido processed with different root crops. Result show that embutido processed with
carrots, sweet potato and sugar beets were all rated very good while embutido with ube
was rated good.
Statistical analysis shows no significant differences among treatments. There was
difference in numerical and verbal description, but was not enough to cause a significant
deviation.
Tenderness
Table 3 shows the tenderness of embutido as evaluated by the panelists. The
embutido with carrots, ube and sugar beets were rated very tender, while the embutido with
sweet potato was rated moderately tender.
Statistical analysis revealed no significant differences among treatments. There was
difference in numerical and verbal description, but was not enough to cause a significant
differences.
Table 2. Appearance of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.32 Very Good
Embutido with ube 1.59 Good
Embutido with sweet potato 1.39 Very Good
Embutido with sugar beets 1.35 Very Good
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 3. Tenderness of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.46 Moderately Tender
Embutido with ube 1.43 Very Tender
Embutido with sweet potato 1.59 Moderately Tender
Embutido with sugar beets 1.39 Very Tender
Juiciness
Table 4 shows that embutido in different treatments were all rated as moderately
juicy by the panelists. Numerically, they had differences, embutido processed with carrots
had 1.69, embutido with ube had 1.71, embutido with sweet potato had 1.73 and embutido
with sugarbeets had 1.65. based on the verbal description of the tasters, the products under
the different treatments were all moderately juicy, thus, resulting to no significant
differences among the treatments.
Acceptability
Table 5 shows the acceptability evaluation of embutido with different root crops.
Embutido with carrots, embutido with sweet potato and embutido with sugar beets were
rated likely very much while embutido with ube was rated like moderately.
Analysis revealed that there are no significant differences among treatments. There was
difference in numerical and verbal description, but was not enough to cause a significant
deviation.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 4. Juiciness of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.69 Moderately Juicy
Embutido with ube 1.71 Moderately Juicy
Embutido with sweet potato 1.73 Moderately Juicy
Embutido with sugar beets 1.65 Moderately Juicy
Table 5. Acceptability of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.39 Like Very Much
Embutido with ube 1.56 Like Moderately
Embutido with Sweet Potato 1.44 Like Very Much
Embutido with Sugar Beets 1.47 Like Very Much
Aroma
Table 6 revealed the result of the aroma as affected by different treatments. It shows
that embutido with carrots, embutido with sweet potato and embutido with sugar beets were
rated by the panelists very pleasing, but based on the numerical value embutido processed
with carrots had the highest value for aroma, and moderately pleasing was the verbal
description for embutido with ube.
Analysis shows no significant differences among treatments. This implies that the different
treatments did not affect the aroma of the products.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 6. Aroma of embutido
TREATMENT MEAN DESCRIPTION
Embutido with carrots 1.36 Very Pleasing
Embutido with ube 1.57 Moderately Pleasing
Embutido with Sweet Potato 1.4 Very Pleasing
Embutido with Sugar Beets 1.47 Very Pleasing
Shelf Life Evaluation
The processed products were observed on the number of days molds appeared.
Embutido with carrots (Figure 17), ube (Figure 18) and sweet potato (Figure 19) exhibited
molds on the 3rd day, while embutido with sugar beets exhibited molds on the 4th day
(Figure 20).
Total Cost of Processed products
The cost of production (Table 7) shows the expenses incurred in processing embutido.
Differences on the expenses incurred in producing embutido are attributed to the
differences in prices of the extenders used. The embutido with sugarbeets had the highest
expense of 323.8225 pesos, while embutido with sweet potato had the lowest expense of
316.3425 pesos.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 7. Total cost of processed embutido per kilogram (Php)
EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO
PROCESSED PROCESSED PROCESSED PROCESSED
INGREDIENTS WITH 250g WITH 250g WITH 250g WITH 250g
CARROTS UBE SWEET SUGAR
POTATO BEETS
Refined salt 0.14 0 .14 0.14 0 .14
Onion 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44
Raisins 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50
Hotdog 27.50 27.50 27.50 27.50
Cornstarch 1.50 1.50 1.50 1.50
Eggs 8.67 8.67 8.67 8.67
Soy 0.68 0.68 0.68 0.68
Cheese 20.25 20.25 20.25 20.25
Bread Crumbs 6.50 6.50 6.50 6.50
Cooking oil 10.83 10.83 10.83 10.83
Garlic 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00
Pickle relish 13.25 13.25 13.25 13.25
Magic sarap 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00
Pork meat 180 180 180 180
Sugar 1.19 1.19 1.19 1.19
Carrot 12.50 - - -
Ube - 13 - -
Sweet potato - - 10 -
Sugar Beets - - - 17
Direct cost 299.95 300.45 297.45 307.45
Indirect cost 18.9975 19.0225 18.8725 19.3725
Total cost of
Production (php) 318.9475 319.4725 316.3425 323.8225
Gross Income 325 325 325 325
Net Income 6.0525 5.5275 8.6575 1.1775
ROI (%) 1.90 1.73 2.74 0.36
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Figure 17. Appearance of embutido with Figure 18. Appearance of embutido with
carrots at 3rd day ube at 3rd day
Figure 19. Appearance of embutido with Figure 20. Appearance of embutido with
sweet potato at 3rd day sugar beets at 4th day
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Nutrition Fact Analysis
Table 8 shows the result of the nutritional content analysis of embutido processed with
different root crops as analyzed by the Department of Science and Technology, Km.6, La
Trinidad, Benguet.
Ash content. Embutido with sweet potato had 2.56% in every 250 grams, embutido with
sugar beets had 2.07%, embutido with carrots had 1.95% and embutido with ube has
1.40%.
Carbohydrates content. Embutido with sweet potato had 20.24% followed by embutido
with sugar beets with 15.85%, embutido with carrots with 12.60% and embutido with ube
with 12.44%.
Crude fat content. Embutido with ube had 9.51%, followed by embutido with sweet potato
had 8.19%, embutido with carrots had 7.89% and embutido with sugar beets had 6.46%.
Crude protein content. Embutido with carrots had 13.6%, then embutido with ube had
12.9%, embutido with sugar beets had 11.32% and embutido with sweet potato had 9.29%.
Moisture content. Embutido with ube had 64.56%, followed by embutido with carrots had
64.51%, embutido with sugar beets had 64.30% and embutido with sweet potato had
59.72%.
Energy content. Embutido with sweet potato had 192kcal, followed by embutido with ube
which is 184kcal, then embutido with carrots which is 174kcal, and lastly the embutido
with sugar beets which contains 167kcal.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
Table 8. Nutrition Facts Analysis as analyzed by the DOST
EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO EMBUTIDO
NUTRIENT PROCESSED PROCESSED PROCESSED PROCESSED
CONTENT WITH 250g WITH 250g WITH 250g WITH 250g
CARROTS UBE SWEET SUGAR
POTATO BEETS
Ash, % 1.95 1.40 2.56 2.07
Carbohydrate, % 12.60 12.44 20.24 15.85
Crude Fat, % 7.89 9.51 8.19 6.46
Crude protein, % 13.06 12.09 9.29 11.32
Moisture, % 64.51 64.56 59.72 64.30
Energy, kcal 174 184 192 167
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
Summary
This was conducted at the Meat Processing Laboratory, Department of Animal
Science, College of Agriculture, Benguet State University, La Trinidad, Benguet. The
study was conducted to determine the acceptability of embutido processed with different
root crops, to determine the production cost and profitability, to determine the nutrient
content and to determine the shelf life of the products. A total of 25 panelists were invited
to evaluate the processed embutido with different root crops. The panels of tasters are
composed of five persons from students, teachers, house wives, employees and food
servers.
The products were evaluated in terms of appearance, tenderness, juiciness
acceptability and aroma. As for tenderness, embutido with carrots, ube and sugar beets
were rated very tender while embutido with carrots and sweet potato was rated by the
panelists as moderately tender. In terms of appearance the panelist rated embutido
processed with carrots, sweet potato, and sugar beets as very good and embutido with ube
as good. For juiciness, all of the products were rated as moderately juicy. For acceptability
embutido with carrots, sweet potato, sugar beets were rated as like very much while
embutido with ube was rated as like moderately. For aroma, embutido with carrots,
embutido with sweet potato and embutido with sugar beets were rated like very much,
while embutido with ube it was rated like moderately.
Nonetheless, results of statistical analysis revealed that there were no significant
differences among the treatments.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
The shelf life of the products was evaluated under room temperature. The products
with carrot, ube and sweet potato deteriorated three days from the time of processing as
exhibited by the presence molds and its foul odor, except for the embutido with sugar beets
which deteriorated on the fourth day. The shelf life evaluation started on May 9, 2011 and
ended on May 13, 2011 which was the deterioration of all the treatments.
Conclusion
Based on the result of the study it is concluded that ube, sweet potato and sugar
beets can be used as alternative extenders for embutido. It is also concluded that the use
of sweet potato as extender can lower the cost production. In addition, adding sugar beets
could lengthen the shelf life of the product and its reddish color enhances the appearance
of the product which makes it more attractive.
Recommendation
To maximize profit, it is recommended that sweet potato be used as extender for
embutido because of its lower price as compared to carrots, ube and sugar beets. Based on
the result of organoleptic test by the tasters, it is generally acceptable. Thus, guaranteeing
its marketability and viability in the market. Moreover, it contains the highest energy
content (192kcal) as compared to other root crops used.
Even so, the other root crops could still be used as extenders for embutido to provide
consumers choices. Not to mention, consumers have different preferences.
Since this study is limited only on the data provided and gathered, it is
recommended that further studies be conducted to validate the results.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012
LITERATURE CITED
ANONYMOUS. 2001. The World’s Healthiest Food. Retrieved April 21, 2011from
http://www.whfoods.com.
ANONYMOUS. 2005. Sweet Potato Nutrition Information and Facts. Retrieved May 6,
2011from http://www.juicing-for-health.com/carrot-nutrition.html.
DIO-AL, T. D. 2005. Evaluation of different Meat as Embutido. BS Thesis. Benguet State
University, La Trinidad Benguet. P4.
ESMINGER A.H. ME Ensminger, JE Kondale, JRK Robson. 1983 Foods and Nutrition
Encyclopedia. Pegus Press, Clovis, California 1983.
IBARRA, P. I. 1983. Meat Processing for Small and Medium Care Operations. University
of the Philippines. Los Banos, Laguna. Pp. 182-189.
LABENSKYand HAUSE 2003. On Cooking, Techniques from Expert Chefs. 3rd Edition.
New Jersy 07458.
RELF D. AND McDANIEL A. 2009. Root Crops Home Virginia Cooperative Extension.
Virginia State University. Retrieved May4, 2011. Http://pubs.ext.vt.edu/426/426-
422/426-422.html.
STAUB, A. 1982. The Science of Philippine Foods 2nd Edition. Abanido Enterprise.
Araneta Center Quezon City, Philippines. P338
The MATELJAN FOUNDATION.2O11. Sweet Potato Nutrition information and Facts.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweet Potato.
UNITED STATES FOOD and DRUGS ADMINISTRATION 2009. Beets Nutrition
Facts. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/beet.
UNITED STATES FOOD and DRUGS ADMINISTRATION 2009. Nutrition: Nutrient
content of Ube. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/yam.
UNITED STATES FOOD and DRUGS ADMINISTRATION 2009. Juicing for health
Carrot Nutrition Fact. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/carrot.
Different Root Crops as Ingredient for Embutido
COMNANG, CLARA D. APRIL 2012