BIBLIOGRAPHY PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011....
BIBLIOGRAPHY
PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011. Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different
Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica charantia) Extract. Benguet State University, La
Trinidad, Benguet.
Adviser: Myrna B. Walsiyen MSc.
ABSTRACT
The study was conducted at the Meat Laboratory Room of the Department of
Animal Science under the College of Agriculture, Benguet State University. This was
conducted to determine the acceptability of pork patties processed with different levels of
ampalaya extract in terms of appearance, tenderness, juiciness, flavor, and the overall
acceptability of the product; to determine the cost of producing meat patties processed
with different levels of ampalaya extract; and to determine the composition of pork patties
processed with different levels of ampalaya extract.
The results of the study revealed that adding ampalaya fruit extract in processing
pork patties at the level of 100-200 ml/kg did not significantly affect the appearance,
juiciness, flavor and the overall acceptability of the product. However, in terms of
tenderness, the inclusion of ampalaya fruit extract at the level of 200 ml/kg meat made the
pork patties less tender. Both the patties with no ampalaya fruit extract and those with
ampalaya fruit extract added at the level of 100 ml/kg meat were more or less similar in
tenderness.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
The results also revealed that the inclusion of ampalaya fruit extract in processing
pork patties at the level of 100-200 ml/kg meat have caused an increase (Php 2.00-4.00) in
the total cost of production. Furthermore, in terms of food composition, it resulted to an
increase in the energy content of the product but caused a reduction in the protein content
ranging from 0.98-1.72%.
Based on the results of the study, ampalaya extract maybe added when making pork
patties for its medicinal value but at the level of 100 ml/kg meat so that the tenderness of
the product will not be reduced, the increase in total cost will not be high, and the reduction
in the protein content will only be slight. However, it is also recommended that further
studies should be conducted to include the micro nutrient contents of the processed product
to confirm its medicinal value and the nutrient composition analysis should be replicated
to have more conclusive results.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
INTRODUCTION
Meat processing is not merely producing a product just to have something to sell,
but the taste and preference of the consumers should be considered. Consumers today are
getting more conscious of their health so they are very selective on the quality and
nutritional value of the products they buy and eat. Researchers have responded by adding
herbs or healthful flavorings to meat during processing such as basil leaves, lemon grass
extract, and corn syrup and are still continously doing researches to satisfy the meat product
consumers.
One of the common herbal plants is the ampalaya. Ampalaya, botanically known
as Momordica charantia, is a tropical and subtropical vine of the family Cucurbitaceae. It
is widely grown in the Philippines for its edible fruit and it is also called bitter melon or
bitter gourd. As the English name suggests, the melon has a bitter taste due to the presence
of momordicin, and is believed to be among the most bitter of all vegetables. Ampalaya is
a climbing vine that grows up to five meters, with tendrils up to twenty centimeters long.
Amplaya leaves are heart-shaped, five to ten centimeters across, cut into five to seven
lobes. Each ampalaya plant bears separate yellow male and female flowers. It bears fleshy
green fruit, oblong shaped with pointed ends, ribbed and wrinkled, bursting when
mature to release seeds. Ampalaya seeds are flat with
ruminated margins (hubpages. com, 2011).
Ampalaya leaves and fruits are excellent sources of Vitamin B, iron, calcium, and
phosphorus. It is also rich in beta carotene. Ampalaya is used as herbal treatment for
diabetes, coughs, skin diseases, hemorrhoids, stomach problems and as purgative.
Scientific studies have also been conducted on ampalaya as a possible cure for cancer and
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
HIV. It has been found to be helpful in treating malaria and is known, like most bitter foods,
to stimulate digestion and relieve constipation. Its leaves are also used as medicine for
wounds, for coughs, to combat sterility in women, as a paraticide and antipyretic. Pounded
ampalaya seeds or leaves are used to treat burns, scalds and wounds (www.
medicalhealthguide.com, 2011).
Because of the above benefits, the researcher has been motivated to determine the
acceptability of pork patties processed with ampalaya extract. Result of this study would
serve as a reference material to students, food processors, other researchers in their future
researches, and other people who are interested to venture on meat processing. It will also
probably help encourage the ampalaya growers to increase their production as this will
be used not only as vegetable but also in meat processing.
Generally, the objective of this study was to determine the acceptability of pork
patties processed with different levels of ampalaya extract. Specifically, this study aimed
to determine the acceptability of pork patties processed with ampalaya extract in terms of
appearance, tenderness, juiciness, flavor , and the overall acceptability of the product; to
determine the cost of producing pork patties processed with ampalaya extract; and to
determine the composition of pork patties processed with ampalaya extract.
This study was conducted at the Meat Laboratory Room of the Department of
Animal Science under the College of Agriculture, Benguet State University, La Trinidad,
Benguet in May 2011.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Bitter gourd, scientifically known as Momordica charantia, is one of the most
popular vegetables in Southeast Asia. It is a member of the cucurbit family along with
cucumber, squash, watermelon, and muskmelon. Native to China or India, the fast-growing
vine is grown throughout Asia and is becoming popular worldwide. Depending on location,
bitter gourd is also known as bitter melon, karella, or balsam pear. The immature fruits and
tender vine tips are used in a variety of culinary preparations (Entre Pinoys Atbp, 2008).
This vegetable is, predictably, very bitter in flavour and it grows easily and the climbing
vine is often seen in kitchen gardens (Hutton, 1998).
According to Doijode (2001), bitter gourd is an important vegetable crop in
Southeast Asia. It is mainly cultivated for its bitter unripe fruits. It is also known as alligator
pear, balsam pear, bitter cucumber, bitter melon, ku gua, and foo gwa. Immature fruits are
cooked as a vegetable. Its leaves and fruits are used in medicine. It is valued for its high
calcium, phosphorus, iron, and its vitamin C contents. Dipping the fruits
in salt water reduces the bitterness.
Medicinal Uses
Since ancient times, plants and herbal preparations have been used as medicine.
Researches carried out in the last few decades had certified several claims on the use of
several plants as traditional medicine. Popularity of Momordica charantia (MC) in various
systems of traditional medicine for several ailments (diabetis, abortifacient, anthelmintic,
contraceptive, dysmenorrhea, eczema, emmenagogue, malaria, galactagogue, gout,
jaundice, abdominal pain, kidney (stone), laxative, leprosy,
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
leucorrhea, piles, pneumonia, psoriasis, purgative, rheumatism, fever and scabies) focused
the investigator’s attention on this plant. Over 100 studies using modern techniques have
authenticated its use in diabetes and its complications (nephropathy, cataract, insulin
resistance), as antibacterial as well as antiviral agent (including HIV infection), as
anthelmintic and abortifacient. Traditionally, it has also been used in treating peptic ulcers.
Interestingly, recent experimental studies have exhibited its potential against Helicobacter
pylori. Most importantly, the studies have shown its efficacy in various cancers such as
lymphoid leukemia, lymphoma, choriocarcinoma, melanoma, breast cancer, skin tumor,
prostatic cancer, squamous carcinoma of tongue and larynx, human bladder carcinomas
and Hodgkin’s disease (Elsevier, 2004).
Romualdez (2004) cited that while ampalaya has long been an Asian traditional
medicine, medicinal value has been concentrated on its use against diabetes. An Indian
study proved that ampalaya increases sensitivity to insulin. In 2007, the Philippine Health
Department mentioned that ampalaya can lower blood-sugar levels. Both these countries
produce ampalaya capsules and export them to many countries, including the
United States.
Culinary Uses
In the Philippines, where it is known as ampalaya, bitter melon is used in many
dishes. It may be stir-fried with ground beef and oyster sauce, or with eggs and diced
tomato. A very popular dish from the Ilocos region in the north of Luzon island is pinakbet,
which consists mainly of bitter melons, eggplant, okra, string beans, tomatoes, lima beans,
and other various regional vegetables alltogether stewed with a little bagoong- based stock.
The young shoots and leaves of the bitter melon may also be eaten as greens; these are
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
locally called “dahon ng ampalaya”. The seeds can also be eaten, and give off a sweet
taste, but have been known to cause vomiting and stomach upset (hubpages. com, 2011).
Apart from Filipinos, ampalaya is used in many other Asian cuisines. In China, it
is used for stir-fried dishes, soups and in tea. In Indonesia, it is stir-fried with coconut milk.
In Vietnam, they have bitter melon soup. In India and Nepal, it is curried or stuffed with
spices before frying in oil. In Pakistan, ampalaya is fried with onions and Okinawans eat a
lot of it, which supposedly accounts for their longer life spans (Romualdez, 2004).
Below are nutrient values of fresh and raw bitter gourd per 100 grams according to
Mangajji, 2010.
Principle
Nutrient value
Percentage of RDA
Energy
17 Kcal
<1
Carbohydrates
3.70 g
3%
Protein
1.00 g
2%
Total fat
0.17 g
0.5%
Cholesterol
0 mg
0%
Dietary fibre 2.80 g
7%
Vitamins
Folates
72 mcg
18%
Niacin
0.400 mg
2.5%
Pantothenic acid 0.212 mg
4%
Pyridoxine
0.043 mg
3%
Riboflavin
0.040 mg
3%
Thiamine
0.040 mg
3.5%
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Vitamin A
471 IU
16%
Vitamin C
84 mg
140%
Electrolytes
Sodium
5 mg
<1%
Potassium
296 mg
6%
Minerals
Calcium
19 mg
2%
Copper
0.034 mg
4%
Iron
0.43 mg
5%
Magnesium
17 mg
4%
Manganese
0.089 mg
4%
Zinc
0.80 mg
7%
Phyto-nutrients
Carotene-B
190 mcg--
Carotene-a
185 mcg--
Lutein-zeaxanthin
170 mcg--
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
The materials used in the study were nine kilograms of ground lean pork and ground
pork fat; fresh ampalaya fruit extract; spices and seasoning ingredients which included
salt, pepper, onions, garlic, eggs, flour, milk powder, hamburger seasoning, and cooking
oil. The other materials that were used include cooking stoves, kitchen knives, frying
pan, mixing bowl, measuring spoons and cups, chopping board, plates, weighing
scale and juicer (Figure 1).
Methodology
Preparation of meat material and ampalaya extract. Fresh meat and fat were
purchased and washed. Lean meat and fat at the ratio of 70:30, respectively, were grinded
after which these were mixed together in a large bowl. On the other hand, good and quality
raw ampalaya fruits were selected (Figure 2). These were washed with water and then
soaked in salt water for about two minutes to lessen its bitterness after which the
ampalaya juice (Figure 3) was extracted using a juicer.
Figure 1. Materials used in the study
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Figure 2. Bitter gourd or ampalaya fruits Figure 3. Ampalaya fruit extract
Experimental treatments. There were three treatments in the study replicated three
times. One kilogram of ground meat (700 g lean pork + 300 g pork fat) was used for each
replication. The treatments were the following:
T0 - 0 ml ampalaya fruit extract
T1 - 100 ml ampalaya fruit extract
T2 - 200 ml ampalaya fruit extract
Making of patties. The patties in all the three treatments were produced using the
same procedure and proportions of ingredients. The only difference was on the level of
ampalaya extract added depending on the treatment where these patties belong. The
procedure followed was as follows. In a mixing bowl, the meat materials (700g ground
lean pork and 300g ground pork fat) were mixed thoroughly. Likewise in a separate bowl,
the different seasonings including table salt (Table 1) were mixed together after which the
resulting mixture was added into the meat material together with the chilled water and the
required level of ampalaya extract and these were mixed thoroughly again. Finally, the
resulting mixture as shown in Figure 4, was refrigerated for two hours to make the
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 1. Ingredients Used for Every Kilogram of Meat
MEAT MATERIALS CURING MIX SEASONINGS
700g pork lean, ground 1 tbsp salt, refined 1/2 tbsp black pepper, ground
300g pork fat, ground 1/2 tbsp water, chilled 1 tbsp garlic, chopped finely
1/2 cup onion, chopped finely
1 tbsp hamburger seasoning
2 tbsp milk powder
1/2 cup flour
2 pcs. medium fresh egg
Figure 4. Meat mixture by treatment ready for molding
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
mixture firm. After refrigeration, the mixture was molded using a hamburger molder to
produce the patties, each patty weighing more or less fifty grams (Figure 5). The patties
produced are then ready for cooking and for the laboratory analysis.
Organoleptic test. From the different treatments, samples of the patties were
obtained and pan-fried separately by treatments (Figure 6). When cooked, these were sliced
into bite sizes (Figure 7), placed in containers with codes and were subjected to the panel
of tasters for evaluation. Each member of the panel of evaluators was given a score sheet
for him to put his ratings. The panel of tasters were composed of five teachers, five
students, five dieticians, five food servers, and five housewives making a total of twenty
five. Organoleptic test was done three times to compose the three replicates per
treatment.
Composition of pork patties. From the different treatments, sample from each was
obtained and labelled accordingly. All the samples were then brought to the Department of
Science and Technology (DOST) – CAR, La Trinidad, Benguet for the analysis of pork
patties composition.
Figure 5. Molded pork patties by treatment
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Figure 6. Deep-fried pork patties by treatment
Figure 7. Bite-sized pork patties by treatment
Data Gathered
1. Appearance of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale:
(1) Very pleasing, (2) Pleasing, (3) Dull.
2. Tenderness of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale:
(1) Very tender, (2) Moderately tender, (3) Tough.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
3. Juiciness of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale: (1) Very
juicy, (2) Moderately juicy, (3) Not juicy.
4. Flavor of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale:
(1) Desirable, (2) Moderately desirable, (3) Undesirable.
5. Acceptability of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale:
(1) Like very much, (2) Like moderately, (3) Dislike.
6. Total cost of production (TCP). This was computed by adding all the cost of
meat and non-meat ingredients used to produce the patties per treatment.
7. Composition of pork patties. These were determined at the DOST - CAR,
La Trinidad, Benguet in terms of ash, carbohydrate/energy, crude fat, crude protein,
and moisture contents of the patties.
Data Analysis
The data gathered were recorded, tabulated and analyzed for differences using the
analysis of variance for Completely Randomized Design (CRD). The Duncan's Multiple
Range Test (DRMT) was used to determine significant differences between treatment
means.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Appearance
Table 2 presents the evaluation of the appearance of the patties in the different
treatments. Differences between means are observable, however, such differences were
still considered small to cause significant effects as revealed by the statistical analysis. This
result implies that the patties produced in all the treatments were more or less similar in
appearance. It is also implied that the addition of ampalaya extract did not greatly alter
the appearance of the patties. For the verbal rating, it follows that the
appearance of the patties in all the treatments were all rated as moderately pleasing.
Tenderness
Table 3 shows the tenderness of the pork patties produced in the different
treatments. No significant difference has been observed between means of the patties
processed with no ampalaya extract and the patties produced with 100 ml ampalaya extract
as revealed by the statistical analysis. However, both of the above, were found to
be more tender than the patties processed with 200 ml ampalaya. The result implies that
Table 2. Ratings for the appearance of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN * VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.9919a Moderately pleasing
100 ml ampalaya extract 2.0820a Moderately pleasing
200 ml ampalaya extract 1.7905a Moderately pleasing
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 3. Ratings for the tenderness of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN* VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.7905b Moderately tender
100 ml ampalaya extract 1.8353b Moderately tender
200 ml ampalaya extract 2.2833a Moderately tender
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
the ampalaya extract, when added in the making of patties at the level of 100 ml/kg meat,
did not reduce the tenderness of the patties, but it made the meat patties less tender
when the level was increased to 200 ml/kg meat.
Juiciness
The ratings for juiciness of the patties in the different treatments are presented in
Table 4. It is presented that there were no significant differences between treatment means
as revealed by the statistical analysis. The result implies that the juiciness of the
patties were more or less similar. It is also implied that the addition of ampalaya extract at
the level of 100 ml-200 ml per kilogram meat into the patties produced did not alter the
juiciness of such patties. In verbal rating, all the patties in the different
treatments were all rated as moderately juicy.
Flavor
Table 5 presents the flavor of the patties in the different treatments as rated by the
members of the taste panel. No significant differences were observed as revealed by the
statistical analysis implying that the patties in all the treatments had more or less the same
flavor. It is also implied that the addition of 100 or even 200 ml of ampalaya extract into
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 4. Ratings for the juiciness of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN* VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.8886a Moderately juicy
100 ml ampalaya extract 1.8752a Moderately juicy
200 ml ampalaya extract 1.9285a Moderately juicy
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
Table 5. Ratings for the flavor of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN* VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.9285a Moderately desirable
100 ml ampalaya extract 1.7059a Moderately desirable
200 ml ampalaya extract 1.7552a Moderately desirable
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
the patties did not alter the flavor of such patties. The patties in the different treatments
were all verbally rated as moderately desirable.
Acceptability
Table 6 shows the acceptability of the patties as rated by members of the taste panel.
Statistical analysis revealed no significant differences between treatment means and all
received a verbal rating of liked moderately. The result implies that 100 to 200 ml of
ampalaya extract may be added to every kilogram of pork processed to produce patties
and still acceptable to consumers.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 6. Ratings for the acceptability of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN* VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.7367a Like moderately
100 ml ampalaya extract 1.7686a Like moderately
200 ml ampalaya extract 1.9285a Like moderately
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
Composition of Pork Patties
Table 7 presents the composition of the pork patties in the different treatments as
analyzed at the DOST-CAR, La Trinidad, Benguet. It is presented that the pork patties with
ampalaya fruit extract added at the level of 100 – 200 ml/kg meat had higher energy and
crude fat contents compared to the pork patties with no ampalaya extract. However,
because the ampalaya fruit extract is not a good protein source, reductions were observed
in the crude protein contents from 15.11% observed from the patties with no ampalaya fruit
extract to 14.13 (difference of 0.98%) observed from the patties with ampalaya fruit
extract added at the rate of 100 ml/kg meat and 13.19% (a difference of 1.72%) observed
from the patties with ampalaya fruit extract added at the level of 200 ml/kg meat. The
results imply that the inclusion of ampalaya fruit extract in making pork patties should be
done not because of its protein content but because of its medicinal value. According to
Elsevier (2004), over 100 studies using modern techniques have authenticated the use of
ampalaya in diabetes, its use as antibacterial as well as antiviral agent and as an
anthelmintic. He also cited that recent studies have shown the efficacy of
ampalaya in various cancers like lymphoid leukemia, lymphoma, choriocarcenoma,
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 7. Composition of pork patties produced in the different treatments*
NUTRIENT PORK PATTY PORK PATTY PORK PATTY
CONTENT W/ 0 ML W/ 100 ML W/ 200 ML
AMPALAYA AMPALAYA AMPALAYA
EXTRACT EXTRACT EXTRACT
Ash, % w/w
1.93
1.56 1.52
Carbohydrate , % w/w 5.84 5.47 0.51
Crude fat, % w/w 8.26 16.81 18.73
Crude protein, % w/w 15.11 14.13 13.39
Moisture, % w/w 68.86 62.03 65.86
Energy, kcal 158.00 230.00 224.00
*As analyzed at the DOST-CAR, La Trinidad, Benguet
prostatic cancer, squamous carcinoma of tongue and larynx, human bladder carcinomas,
and Hodgekin’s disease. Similarly, Romualdez (2004) cited that an Indian study proved
that ampalaya increases sensitivity to insulin and in 2007, the Philippine
Health Department mentioned that ampalaya can lower blood sugar levels.
Total Cost of Production
Table 8 presents the cost of producing the patties in the different treatments. As
presented, higher expenses were revealed from the pork patties processed with ampalaya
extract compared to those with no ampalaya extract. This was because of the additional
expense brought about by the cost of ampalaya extract. The inclusion of ampalaya fruit
extract may have increased the total cost of producing the patties but anyway, many of the
consumers of today would still buy processed product even at a higher price in exchange
for the improved quality of the product and for as long as the increase in price
is not too much.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 8. Total cost of producing pork patties for every kilogram of meat by treatment
INGREDIENTS PATTY W/ 0 ML PATTY W/ 100 ML PATTY W/ 200 ML
AMPALAYA AMPALAYA AMPALAYA
EXTRACT EXTRACT EXTRACT
(Php) (Php) (Php)
Pork lean and
pork fat, ground 180.00
180.00 180.00
Onion, finely chopped 5.00
5.00 5.00
Garlic, chopped finely 3.00
3.00 3.00
Hamburger seasoning 3.00
3.00 3.00
Medium fresh eggs 10.00
10.00 10.00
Black pepper 0.20
0.20 0.20
Milk powder 1.50
1.50 1.50
Cooking oil 5.00
5.00 5.00
Ampalaya 2.00 4.00
Table salt 0.20
0.20 0.20
Total Cost of
Production (Php) 206.90 208.90 210.90
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION, AND RECOMMENDATION
Summary
This study was conducted at the Meat Processing Laboratory of the Department of
Animal Science under the College of Agriculture, Benguet State University, La Trinidad,
Benguet. The study was conducted to determine the acceptability of pork patties processed
with different levels of ampalaya fruit extract in terms of appearance, juiciness, tenderness,
flavor, and the overall acceptability of the product; to determine the cost of producing meat
patties processed with different levels of ampalaya fruit extract; and to determine the
composition of pork patties processed with different levels of ampalaya fruit extract.
A total of 9 kilograms of pork was used in the study. This was equally divided into
three to compose the three treatments and each treatment had three replications with one
kilogram per replication.
All the patties in the three treatments were processed following the same procedure
and the same levels of meat and non-meat materials. The only difference was in the level
of ampalaya extract added during the processing of patties. No ampalaya extract was added
in the patties produced in the control group (T0); 100 ml of ampalaya extract was added for
every kilogram of meat used to produce the patties in treatment 1 and 200 ml of ampalaya
extract was added for every kilogram of meat used to produce the patties in treatment 2.
Results of the study revealed that except for tenderness, where a significant
difference was observed, no significant differences between treatment means were
observed in terms of appearance, juiciness, flavor, and the overall acceptability of the
patties as evaluated by the panel of tasters. The non-significant results reveal that the
patties produced in all the treatments, with or without ampalaya extract were more or less
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
similar in appearance, juiciness, and flavor. All the patties in all the treatments were all
liked moderately by the panel of tasters. However, in terms of tenderness, the patties with
ampalaya extract added at the level of 200 ml/kg meat, were found to be less tender
compared to the patties with no ampalaya extract and even those with ampalaya extract
added at the level of 100 ml/kg meat.
In terms of food composition, though this was not subjected to statistical analysis,
the laboratory test revealed that the patties with ampalaya extract had higher energy and
crude fat contents than the patties with no ampalaya extract. However, slight reductions in
the crude protein and ash contents were observed from the patties with ampalaya extract
compared to those patties with no ampalaya extract.
Finally, in terms of total cost of production, the patties with ampalaya extract
incurred higher total costs because of the additional expense on the ampalaya extract
compared to the patties with no ampalaya extract.
Conclusion
Based on the results of the study, it is therefore concluded that ampalaya fruit
extract can be used as one of the ingredients in processing pork patties at the rate of 100
ml/kg meat without greatly affecting the appearance, tenderness, juiciness, flavor and the
overall acceptability of the pork patties. It could also be concluded that though the addition
of ampalaya extract caused an increase in the crude fat content and/or energy content as a
whole, this result is inconclusive as no replications have been made on the nutrient
composition analysis.
Recommendation
Based on the results of the study, ampalaya extract maybe added when making pork
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
patties but at the level of 100 ml/kg meat so that the tenderness of the product will not be
reduced, the increase in total cost will not be high, and the reduction in the protein content
will only be slight. However, it is also recommended that further studies should be
conducted to include the micro nutrient contents of the processed product to confirm its
medicinal value and the nutrient composition analysis should be replicated to have more
conclusive results.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
LITERATURE CITED
DOIJODE, S. D. 2001. Seed Storage of Horticultural Crops. New York. Food Product
Press. P. 299.
ELSEVIER B. V. 2004. Journal of Ethnopharmacology. Pp. 123-132. Retrieved April
20, 2011 from http: //www.sciencedirect.com/science
ENTREPINOYS ATBP. 2008. Guide to Growing Bitter Gourd. Retrieved April 20,
2011 from http://www. mixph. com/2008/11/ guide - to - growing - bitter - gourd-
ampalaya.html
HUBPAGES. 2011. Ampalaya’s Culinary Uses. Retrieved April 20, 2011 from
http:hubpages.com/hub/ampalaya-culinary-uses
HUTTON, W. 1998. Tropical Fruits of the Philippines. Periphus Edition (HK) Ltd. P.
23.
MANGAJJI, U. 2010. Bitter Gourd Nutrition Facts. Retrieved August 18, 2011 from
htttp://www.nutrition-and-you.com/bitter-gourd.html
MEDICAL HEALTH GUIDE. 2011. Ampalaya Uses. Retrieved April 18,2011 from
http://www.medicalhealthguide.com/articles/ampalaya.html
ROMUALDEZ, V. 2004. The History of Ampalaya. Retrieved April 20, 2011 from
http: www. Ehow. com. com/ about 5393643 history-ampalaya.html
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011. Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different
Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica charantia) Extract. Benguet State University, La
Trinidad, Benguet.
Adviser: Myrna B. Walsiyen MSc.
ABSTRACT
The study was conducted at the Meat Laboratory Room of the Department of
Animal Science under the College of Agriculture, Benguet State University. This was
conducted to determine the acceptability of pork patties processed with different levels of
ampalaya extract in terms of appearance, tenderness, juiciness, flavor, and the overall
acceptability of the product; to determine the cost of producing meat patties processed
with different levels of ampalaya extract; and to determine the composition of pork patties
processed with different levels of ampalaya extract.
The results of the study revealed that adding ampalaya fruit extract in processing
pork patties at the level of 100-200 ml/kg did not significantly affect the appearance,
juiciness, flavor and the overall acceptability of the product. However, in terms of
tenderness, the inclusion of ampalaya fruit extract at the level of 200 ml/kg meat made the
pork patties less tender. Both the patties with no ampalaya fruit extract and those with
ampalaya fruit extract added at the level of 100 ml/kg meat were more or less similar in
tenderness.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
The results also revealed that the inclusion of ampalaya fruit extract in processing
pork patties at the level of 100-200 ml/kg meat have caused an increase (Php 2.00-4.00) in
the total cost of production. Furthermore, in terms of food composition, it resulted to an
increase in the energy content of the product but caused a reduction in the protein content
ranging from 0.98-1.72%.
Based on the results of the study, ampalaya extract maybe added when making pork
patties for its medicinal value but at the level of 100 ml/kg meat so that the tenderness of
the product will not be reduced, the increase in total cost will not be high, and the reduction
in the protein content will only be slight. However, it is also recommended that further
studies should be conducted to include the micro nutrient contents of the processed product
to confirm its medicinal value and the nutrient composition analysis should be replicated
to have more conclusive results.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
INTRODUCTION
Meat processing is not merely producing a product just to have something to sell,
but the taste and preference of the consumers should be considered. Consumers today are
getting more conscious of their health so they are very selective on the quality and
nutritional value of the products they buy and eat. Researchers have responded by adding
herbs or healthful flavorings to meat during processing such as basil leaves, lemon grass
extract, and corn syrup and are still continously doing researches to satisfy the meat product
consumers.
One of the common herbal plants is the ampalaya. Ampalaya, botanically known
as Momordica charantia, is a tropical and subtropical vine of the family Cucurbitaceae. It
is widely grown in the Philippines for its edible fruit and it is also called bitter melon or
bitter gourd. As the English name suggests, the melon has a bitter taste due to the presence
of momordicin, and is believed to be among the most bitter of all vegetables. Ampalaya is
a climbing vine that grows up to five meters, with tendrils up to twenty centimeters long.
Amplaya leaves are heart-shaped, five to ten centimeters across, cut into five to seven
lobes. Each ampalaya plant bears separate yellow male and female flowers. It bears fleshy
green fruit, oblong shaped with pointed ends, ribbed and wrinkled, bursting when
mature to release seeds. Ampalaya seeds are flat with
ruminated margins (hubpages. com, 2011).
Ampalaya leaves and fruits are excellent sources of Vitamin B, iron, calcium, and
phosphorus. It is also rich in beta carotene. Ampalaya is used as herbal treatment for
diabetes, coughs, skin diseases, hemorrhoids, stomach problems and as purgative.
Scientific studies have also been conducted on ampalaya as a possible cure for cancer and
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
HIV. It has been found to be helpful in treating malaria and is known, like most bitter foods,
to stimulate digestion and relieve constipation. Its leaves are also used as medicine for
wounds, for coughs, to combat sterility in women, as a paraticide and antipyretic. Pounded
ampalaya seeds or leaves are used to treat burns, scalds and wounds (www.
medicalhealthguide.com, 2011).
Because of the above benefits, the researcher has been motivated to determine the
acceptability of pork patties processed with ampalaya extract. Result of this study would
serve as a reference material to students, food processors, other researchers in their future
researches, and other people who are interested to venture on meat processing. It will also
probably help encourage the ampalaya growers to increase their production as this will
be used not only as vegetable but also in meat processing.
Generally, the objective of this study was to determine the acceptability of pork
patties processed with different levels of ampalaya extract. Specifically, this study aimed
to determine the acceptability of pork patties processed with ampalaya extract in terms of
appearance, tenderness, juiciness, flavor , and the overall acceptability of the product; to
determine the cost of producing pork patties processed with ampalaya extract; and to
determine the composition of pork patties processed with ampalaya extract.
This study was conducted at the Meat Laboratory Room of the Department of
Animal Science under the College of Agriculture, Benguet State University, La Trinidad,
Benguet in May 2011.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Bitter gourd, scientifically known as Momordica charantia, is one of the most
popular vegetables in Southeast Asia. It is a member of the cucurbit family along with
cucumber, squash, watermelon, and muskmelon. Native to China or India, the fast-growing
vine is grown throughout Asia and is becoming popular worldwide. Depending on location,
bitter gourd is also known as bitter melon, karella, or balsam pear. The immature fruits and
tender vine tips are used in a variety of culinary preparations (Entre Pinoys Atbp, 2008).
This vegetable is, predictably, very bitter in flavour and it grows easily and the climbing
vine is often seen in kitchen gardens (Hutton, 1998).
According to Doijode (2001), bitter gourd is an important vegetable crop in
Southeast Asia. It is mainly cultivated for its bitter unripe fruits. It is also known as alligator
pear, balsam pear, bitter cucumber, bitter melon, ku gua, and foo gwa. Immature fruits are
cooked as a vegetable. Its leaves and fruits are used in medicine. It is valued for its high
calcium, phosphorus, iron, and its vitamin C contents. Dipping the fruits
in salt water reduces the bitterness.
Medicinal Uses
Since ancient times, plants and herbal preparations have been used as medicine.
Researches carried out in the last few decades had certified several claims on the use of
several plants as traditional medicine. Popularity of Momordica charantia (MC) in various
systems of traditional medicine for several ailments (diabetis, abortifacient, anthelmintic,
contraceptive, dysmenorrhea, eczema, emmenagogue, malaria, galactagogue, gout,
jaundice, abdominal pain, kidney (stone), laxative, leprosy,
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
leucorrhea, piles, pneumonia, psoriasis, purgative, rheumatism, fever and scabies) focused
the investigator’s attention on this plant. Over 100 studies using modern techniques have
authenticated its use in diabetes and its complications (nephropathy, cataract, insulin
resistance), as antibacterial as well as antiviral agent (including HIV infection), as
anthelmintic and abortifacient. Traditionally, it has also been used in treating peptic ulcers.
Interestingly, recent experimental studies have exhibited its potential against Helicobacter
pylori. Most importantly, the studies have shown its efficacy in various cancers such as
lymphoid leukemia, lymphoma, choriocarcinoma, melanoma, breast cancer, skin tumor,
prostatic cancer, squamous carcinoma of tongue and larynx, human bladder carcinomas
and Hodgkin’s disease (Elsevier, 2004).
Romualdez (2004) cited that while ampalaya has long been an Asian traditional
medicine, medicinal value has been concentrated on its use against diabetes. An Indian
study proved that ampalaya increases sensitivity to insulin. In 2007, the Philippine Health
Department mentioned that ampalaya can lower blood-sugar levels. Both these countries
produce ampalaya capsules and export them to many countries, including the
United States.
Culinary Uses
In the Philippines, where it is known as ampalaya, bitter melon is used in many
dishes. It may be stir-fried with ground beef and oyster sauce, or with eggs and diced
tomato. A very popular dish from the Ilocos region in the north of Luzon island is pinakbet,
which consists mainly of bitter melons, eggplant, okra, string beans, tomatoes, lima beans,
and other various regional vegetables alltogether stewed with a little bagoong- based stock.
The young shoots and leaves of the bitter melon may also be eaten as greens; these are
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
locally called “dahon ng ampalaya”. The seeds can also be eaten, and give off a sweet
taste, but have been known to cause vomiting and stomach upset (hubpages. com, 2011).
Apart from Filipinos, ampalaya is used in many other Asian cuisines. In China, it
is used for stir-fried dishes, soups and in tea. In Indonesia, it is stir-fried with coconut milk.
In Vietnam, they have bitter melon soup. In India and Nepal, it is curried or stuffed with
spices before frying in oil. In Pakistan, ampalaya is fried with onions and Okinawans eat a
lot of it, which supposedly accounts for their longer life spans (Romualdez, 2004).
Below are nutrient values of fresh and raw bitter gourd per 100 grams according to
Mangajji, 2010.
Principle
Nutrient value
Percentage of RDA
Energy
17 Kcal
<1
Carbohydrates
3.70 g
3%
Protein
1.00 g
2%
Total fat
0.17 g
0.5%
Cholesterol
0 mg
0%
Dietary fibre 2.80 g
7%
Vitamins
Folates
72 mcg
18%
Niacin
0.400 mg
2.5%
Pantothenic acid 0.212 mg
4%
Pyridoxine
0.043 mg
3%
Riboflavin
0.040 mg
3%
Thiamine
0.040 mg
3.5%
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Vitamin A
471 IU
16%
Vitamin C
84 mg
140%
Electrolytes
Sodium
5 mg
<1%
Potassium
296 mg
6%
Minerals
Calcium
19 mg
2%
Copper
0.034 mg
4%
Iron
0.43 mg
5%
Magnesium
17 mg
4%
Manganese
0.089 mg
4%
Zinc
0.80 mg
7%
Phyto-nutrients
Carotene-B
190 mcg--
Carotene-a
185 mcg--
Lutein-zeaxanthin
170 mcg--
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
The materials used in the study were nine kilograms of ground lean pork and ground
pork fat; fresh ampalaya fruit extract; spices and seasoning ingredients which included
salt, pepper, onions, garlic, eggs, flour, milk powder, hamburger seasoning, and cooking
oil. The other materials that were used include cooking stoves, kitchen knives, frying
pan, mixing bowl, measuring spoons and cups, chopping board, plates, weighing
scale and juicer (Figure 1).
Methodology
Preparation of meat material and ampalaya extract. Fresh meat and fat were
purchased and washed. Lean meat and fat at the ratio of 70:30, respectively, were grinded
after which these were mixed together in a large bowl. On the other hand, good and quality
raw ampalaya fruits were selected (Figure 2). These were washed with water and then
soaked in salt water for about two minutes to lessen its bitterness after which the
ampalaya juice (Figure 3) was extracted using a juicer.
Figure 1. Materials used in the study
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Figure 2. Bitter gourd or ampalaya fruits Figure 3. Ampalaya fruit extract
Experimental treatments. There were three treatments in the study replicated three
times. One kilogram of ground meat (700 g lean pork + 300 g pork fat) was used for each
replication. The treatments were the following:
T0 - 0 ml ampalaya fruit extract
T1 - 100 ml ampalaya fruit extract
T2 - 200 ml ampalaya fruit extract
Making of patties. The patties in all the three treatments were produced using the
same procedure and proportions of ingredients. The only difference was on the level of
ampalaya extract added depending on the treatment where these patties belong. The
procedure followed was as follows. In a mixing bowl, the meat materials (700g ground
lean pork and 300g ground pork fat) were mixed thoroughly. Likewise in a separate bowl,
the different seasonings including table salt (Table 1) were mixed together after which the
resulting mixture was added into the meat material together with the chilled water and the
required level of ampalaya extract and these were mixed thoroughly again. Finally, the
resulting mixture as shown in Figure 4, was refrigerated for two hours to make the
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 1. Ingredients Used for Every Kilogram of Meat
MEAT MATERIALS CURING MIX SEASONINGS
700g pork lean, ground 1 tbsp salt, refined 1/2 tbsp black pepper, ground
300g pork fat, ground 1/2 tbsp water, chilled 1 tbsp garlic, chopped finely
1/2 cup onion, chopped finely
1 tbsp hamburger seasoning
2 tbsp milk powder
1/2 cup flour
2 pcs. medium fresh egg
Figure 4. Meat mixture by treatment ready for molding
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
mixture firm. After refrigeration, the mixture was molded using a hamburger molder to
produce the patties, each patty weighing more or less fifty grams (Figure 5). The patties
produced are then ready for cooking and for the laboratory analysis.
Organoleptic test. From the different treatments, samples of the patties were
obtained and pan-fried separately by treatments (Figure 6). When cooked, these were sliced
into bite sizes (Figure 7), placed in containers with codes and were subjected to the panel
of tasters for evaluation. Each member of the panel of evaluators was given a score sheet
for him to put his ratings. The panel of tasters were composed of five teachers, five
students, five dieticians, five food servers, and five housewives making a total of twenty
five. Organoleptic test was done three times to compose the three replicates per
treatment.
Composition of pork patties. From the different treatments, sample from each was
obtained and labelled accordingly. All the samples were then brought to the Department of
Science and Technology (DOST) – CAR, La Trinidad, Benguet for the analysis of pork
patties composition.
Figure 5. Molded pork patties by treatment
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Figure 6. Deep-fried pork patties by treatment
Figure 7. Bite-sized pork patties by treatment
Data Gathered
1. Appearance of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale:
(1) Very pleasing, (2) Pleasing, (3) Dull.
2. Tenderness of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale:
(1) Very tender, (2) Moderately tender, (3) Tough.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
3. Juiciness of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale: (1) Very
juicy, (2) Moderately juicy, (3) Not juicy.
4. Flavor of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale:
(1) Desirable, (2) Moderately desirable, (3) Undesirable.
5. Acceptability of the product. Each sample was evaluated using the scale:
(1) Like very much, (2) Like moderately, (3) Dislike.
6. Total cost of production (TCP). This was computed by adding all the cost of
meat and non-meat ingredients used to produce the patties per treatment.
7. Composition of pork patties. These were determined at the DOST - CAR,
La Trinidad, Benguet in terms of ash, carbohydrate/energy, crude fat, crude protein,
and moisture contents of the patties.
Data Analysis
The data gathered were recorded, tabulated and analyzed for differences using the
analysis of variance for Completely Randomized Design (CRD). The Duncan's Multiple
Range Test (DRMT) was used to determine significant differences between treatment
means.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Appearance
Table 2 presents the evaluation of the appearance of the patties in the different
treatments. Differences between means are observable, however, such differences were
still considered small to cause significant effects as revealed by the statistical analysis. This
result implies that the patties produced in all the treatments were more or less similar in
appearance. It is also implied that the addition of ampalaya extract did not greatly alter
the appearance of the patties. For the verbal rating, it follows that the
appearance of the patties in all the treatments were all rated as moderately pleasing.
Tenderness
Table 3 shows the tenderness of the pork patties produced in the different
treatments. No significant difference has been observed between means of the patties
processed with no ampalaya extract and the patties produced with 100 ml ampalaya extract
as revealed by the statistical analysis. However, both of the above, were found to
be more tender than the patties processed with 200 ml ampalaya. The result implies that
Table 2. Ratings for the appearance of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN * VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.9919a Moderately pleasing
100 ml ampalaya extract 2.0820a Moderately pleasing
200 ml ampalaya extract 1.7905a Moderately pleasing
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 3. Ratings for the tenderness of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN* VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.7905b Moderately tender
100 ml ampalaya extract 1.8353b Moderately tender
200 ml ampalaya extract 2.2833a Moderately tender
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
the ampalaya extract, when added in the making of patties at the level of 100 ml/kg meat,
did not reduce the tenderness of the patties, but it made the meat patties less tender
when the level was increased to 200 ml/kg meat.
Juiciness
The ratings for juiciness of the patties in the different treatments are presented in
Table 4. It is presented that there were no significant differences between treatment means
as revealed by the statistical analysis. The result implies that the juiciness of the
patties were more or less similar. It is also implied that the addition of ampalaya extract at
the level of 100 ml-200 ml per kilogram meat into the patties produced did not alter the
juiciness of such patties. In verbal rating, all the patties in the different
treatments were all rated as moderately juicy.
Flavor
Table 5 presents the flavor of the patties in the different treatments as rated by the
members of the taste panel. No significant differences were observed as revealed by the
statistical analysis implying that the patties in all the treatments had more or less the same
flavor. It is also implied that the addition of 100 or even 200 ml of ampalaya extract into
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 4. Ratings for the juiciness of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN* VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.8886a Moderately juicy
100 ml ampalaya extract 1.8752a Moderately juicy
200 ml ampalaya extract 1.9285a Moderately juicy
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
Table 5. Ratings for the flavor of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN* VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.9285a Moderately desirable
100 ml ampalaya extract 1.7059a Moderately desirable
200 ml ampalaya extract 1.7552a Moderately desirable
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
the patties did not alter the flavor of such patties. The patties in the different treatments
were all verbally rated as moderately desirable.
Acceptability
Table 6 shows the acceptability of the patties as rated by members of the taste panel.
Statistical analysis revealed no significant differences between treatment means and all
received a verbal rating of liked moderately. The result implies that 100 to 200 ml of
ampalaya extract may be added to every kilogram of pork processed to produce patties
and still acceptable to consumers.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 6. Ratings for the acceptability of pork patties in the different treatments
TREATMENT MEAN* VERBAL RATING
0 ml ampalaya extract 1.7367a Like moderately
100 ml ampalaya extract 1.7686a Like moderately
200 ml ampalaya extract 1.9285a Like moderately
*Means with the same letter are not significantly different at 5% DMRT
Composition of Pork Patties
Table 7 presents the composition of the pork patties in the different treatments as
analyzed at the DOST-CAR, La Trinidad, Benguet. It is presented that the pork patties with
ampalaya fruit extract added at the level of 100 – 200 ml/kg meat had higher energy and
crude fat contents compared to the pork patties with no ampalaya extract. However,
because the ampalaya fruit extract is not a good protein source, reductions were observed
in the crude protein contents from 15.11% observed from the patties with no ampalaya fruit
extract to 14.13 (difference of 0.98%) observed from the patties with ampalaya fruit
extract added at the rate of 100 ml/kg meat and 13.19% (a difference of 1.72%) observed
from the patties with ampalaya fruit extract added at the level of 200 ml/kg meat. The
results imply that the inclusion of ampalaya fruit extract in making pork patties should be
done not because of its protein content but because of its medicinal value. According to
Elsevier (2004), over 100 studies using modern techniques have authenticated the use of
ampalaya in diabetes, its use as antibacterial as well as antiviral agent and as an
anthelmintic. He also cited that recent studies have shown the efficacy of
ampalaya in various cancers like lymphoid leukemia, lymphoma, choriocarcenoma,
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 7. Composition of pork patties produced in the different treatments*
NUTRIENT PORK PATTY PORK PATTY PORK PATTY
CONTENT W/ 0 ML W/ 100 ML W/ 200 ML
AMPALAYA AMPALAYA AMPALAYA
EXTRACT EXTRACT EXTRACT
Ash, % w/w
1.93
1.56 1.52
Carbohydrate , % w/w 5.84 5.47 0.51
Crude fat, % w/w 8.26 16.81 18.73
Crude protein, % w/w 15.11 14.13 13.39
Moisture, % w/w 68.86 62.03 65.86
Energy, kcal 158.00 230.00 224.00
*As analyzed at the DOST-CAR, La Trinidad, Benguet
prostatic cancer, squamous carcinoma of tongue and larynx, human bladder carcinomas,
and Hodgekin’s disease. Similarly, Romualdez (2004) cited that an Indian study proved
that ampalaya increases sensitivity to insulin and in 2007, the Philippine
Health Department mentioned that ampalaya can lower blood sugar levels.
Total Cost of Production
Table 8 presents the cost of producing the patties in the different treatments. As
presented, higher expenses were revealed from the pork patties processed with ampalaya
extract compared to those with no ampalaya extract. This was because of the additional
expense brought about by the cost of ampalaya extract. The inclusion of ampalaya fruit
extract may have increased the total cost of producing the patties but anyway, many of the
consumers of today would still buy processed product even at a higher price in exchange
for the improved quality of the product and for as long as the increase in price
is not too much.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
Table 8. Total cost of producing pork patties for every kilogram of meat by treatment
INGREDIENTS PATTY W/ 0 ML PATTY W/ 100 ML PATTY W/ 200 ML
AMPALAYA AMPALAYA AMPALAYA
EXTRACT EXTRACT EXTRACT
(Php) (Php) (Php)
Pork lean and
pork fat, ground 180.00
180.00 180.00
Onion, finely chopped 5.00
5.00 5.00
Garlic, chopped finely 3.00
3.00 3.00
Hamburger seasoning 3.00
3.00 3.00
Medium fresh eggs 10.00
10.00 10.00
Black pepper 0.20
0.20 0.20
Milk powder 1.50
1.50 1.50
Cooking oil 5.00
5.00 5.00
Ampalaya 2.00 4.00
Table salt 0.20
0.20 0.20
Total Cost of
Production (Php) 206.90 208.90 210.90
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION, AND RECOMMENDATION
Summary
This study was conducted at the Meat Processing Laboratory of the Department of
Animal Science under the College of Agriculture, Benguet State University, La Trinidad,
Benguet. The study was conducted to determine the acceptability of pork patties processed
with different levels of ampalaya fruit extract in terms of appearance, juiciness, tenderness,
flavor, and the overall acceptability of the product; to determine the cost of producing meat
patties processed with different levels of ampalaya fruit extract; and to determine the
composition of pork patties processed with different levels of ampalaya fruit extract.
A total of 9 kilograms of pork was used in the study. This was equally divided into
three to compose the three treatments and each treatment had three replications with one
kilogram per replication.
All the patties in the three treatments were processed following the same procedure
and the same levels of meat and non-meat materials. The only difference was in the level
of ampalaya extract added during the processing of patties. No ampalaya extract was added
in the patties produced in the control group (T0); 100 ml of ampalaya extract was added for
every kilogram of meat used to produce the patties in treatment 1 and 200 ml of ampalaya
extract was added for every kilogram of meat used to produce the patties in treatment 2.
Results of the study revealed that except for tenderness, where a significant
difference was observed, no significant differences between treatment means were
observed in terms of appearance, juiciness, flavor, and the overall acceptability of the
patties as evaluated by the panel of tasters. The non-significant results reveal that the
patties produced in all the treatments, with or without ampalaya extract were more or less
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
similar in appearance, juiciness, and flavor. All the patties in all the treatments were all
liked moderately by the panel of tasters. However, in terms of tenderness, the patties with
ampalaya extract added at the level of 200 ml/kg meat, were found to be less tender
compared to the patties with no ampalaya extract and even those with ampalaya extract
added at the level of 100 ml/kg meat.
In terms of food composition, though this was not subjected to statistical analysis,
the laboratory test revealed that the patties with ampalaya extract had higher energy and
crude fat contents than the patties with no ampalaya extract. However, slight reductions in
the crude protein and ash contents were observed from the patties with ampalaya extract
compared to those patties with no ampalaya extract.
Finally, in terms of total cost of production, the patties with ampalaya extract
incurred higher total costs because of the additional expense on the ampalaya extract
compared to the patties with no ampalaya extract.
Conclusion
Based on the results of the study, it is therefore concluded that ampalaya fruit
extract can be used as one of the ingredients in processing pork patties at the rate of 100
ml/kg meat without greatly affecting the appearance, tenderness, juiciness, flavor and the
overall acceptability of the pork patties. It could also be concluded that though the addition
of ampalaya extract caused an increase in the crude fat content and/or energy content as a
whole, this result is inconclusive as no replications have been made on the nutrient
composition analysis.
Recommendation
Based on the results of the study, ampalaya extract maybe added when making pork
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
patties but at the level of 100 ml/kg meat so that the tenderness of the product will not be
reduced, the increase in total cost will not be high, and the reduction in the protein content
will only be slight. However, it is also recommended that further studies should be
conducted to include the micro nutrient contents of the processed product to confirm its
medicinal value and the nutrient composition analysis should be replicated to have more
conclusive results.
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011
LITERATURE CITED
DOIJODE, S. D. 2001. Seed Storage of Horticultural Crops. New York. Food Product
Press. P. 299.
ELSEVIER B. V. 2004. Journal of Ethnopharmacology. Pp. 123-132. Retrieved April
20, 2011 from http: //www.sciencedirect.com/science
ENTREPINOYS ATBP. 2008. Guide to Growing Bitter Gourd. Retrieved April 20,
2011 from http://www. mixph. com/2008/11/ guide - to - growing - bitter - gourd-
ampalaya.html
HUBPAGES. 2011. Ampalaya’s Culinary Uses. Retrieved April 20, 2011 from
http:hubpages.com/hub/ampalaya-culinary-uses
HUTTON, W. 1998. Tropical Fruits of the Philippines. Periphus Edition (HK) Ltd. P.
23.
MANGAJJI, U. 2010. Bitter Gourd Nutrition Facts. Retrieved August 18, 2011 from
htttp://www.nutrition-and-you.com/bitter-gourd.html
MEDICAL HEALTH GUIDE. 2011. Ampalaya Uses. Retrieved April 18,2011 from
http://www.medicalhealthguide.com/articles/ampalaya.html
ROMUALDEZ, V. 2004. The History of Ampalaya. Retrieved April 20, 2011 from
http: www. Ehow. com. com/ about 5393643 history-ampalaya.html
Evaluation of Pork Patties Processed with Different Levels of Ampalaya (Momordica
charantia) Extract | PE, MARITES O. JUNE 2011